| b 18 Aug 1889, , Sevier, Tennessee | ||||
| | | ||||
| Mitchell Smith Valentine | ||||
| |b 16 Oct 1862 | | | |||
| |d 12 Aug 1933 | ||||
| | | ||||
| Mary Maude Valentine | William Marshall | |||
| |Mansfield Webb | John Marshall | | | Jacob Hoover Shields | b 1767 | Robert Shields | > |
| | | |b 18 Jul 1831 | Sarah Shields | Sabra White | > |
| Elizabeth Angeline Shields | d 19 Dec 1862 | b 1800 | Valentine | |
| b 31 Oct 1857 | | | Henry Valentine | ||
| d 16 Jan 1928 | Rebecca Valentine | b 1795 | Green | |
| b 16 May 1831 | Dorcus Angeline Green | |||
| d 08 Oct 1911 | ||||
Source: 'Shields Family', Christine B. Brown, 6 February 1980, p 109.